Customize Your Cookies With This Simple Dough Recipe

Bring on the cookies! Use our "goes with anything" dough recipe and discover 6 ways to customize.

The winter season brings carolers, candy canes and our personal favorite, holiday cookies! Even if you love cookies as much as we do, eating the same cookie all season long can get a bit boring. But who has time to bake a variety of flavors and styles?

Luckily, there’s no need to compromise your cookies. Instead, try our “goes with anything” cookie dough recipe, which yields 12 to 15 cookies per batch:

1 egg + 1½ cups flour + ¾ teaspoon baking powder + 1½ sticks butter + ¾ cup sugar + ½ teaspoon sea salt + ½ tablespoon vanilla

The best part of our “one dough fits all” recipe? It gives you the freedom to personalize! You can easily modify the sweet vanilla base dough to make a whole new festive cookie. If you aren’t sure where to start, we’ve got six customizable ideas to help get the dough rolling.

Tip: Clean up your cookie-making mess with multipurpose spray from Home Made Simple. It’s effective, plant-based and free from dyes, parabens and phthalates.

6 Cookie Recipes Using Our Simple Cookie Dough

  1. Salty and sweet: Add sea salt and chocolate chips to the dough.
  2. Peanut butter paradise: Add peanut butter to taste for a sweet-and-savory classic.
  3. Lemon lover’s delight: After baking, add lemon glaze and powdered sugar to the top.

Tip: Lemon-scented hands are lovely, but sticky dough and powdered sugar? Not so much. Keep the lemon and kiss the baking mess goodbye with lemon-scented foaming hand soap from Home Made Simple.

  1. Jammin’ out: Make a thumbprint in the cookie and add jam before baking.
  2. Sprinkle city: Dip the cookie in melted white chocolate mixed with food coloring, and add sprinkles for an adorable pop of color.
  3. Coffee break: Instead of adding chocolate chips, sprinkle chocolate-covered coffee beans! This cookie is tiramisu’s tasty cousin — perfect for the coffee lovers at your holiday party.

Tip: Do you struggle to incorporate butter into flour? We love this cooking hack: Grate frozen butter, and then toss and coat the flour with the grated pieces. This will help evenly distribute the butter for consistent flavor.

So there you have it: six cookies, one dough. Start with our ideas, dream up a few of your own and amaze your guests with a variety of sweet-treat choices. Let’s get baking!

Related Articles

Favorite Fall Flavors: Turn 3 Classic Pies Into Cheesecakes

Transform these 3 classic pie recipes into mini cheesecakes for a treat the whole family will love.

Pie, Oh Pie: How To Bake Mini Pies With Big Flavor

From apple pie to savory turkey pot pie, follow our 3 simple steps to create mini pies for any gathering.

How To Host A Seafood Boil

Turn your traditional backyard barbecue into a party to remember by hosting a seafood boil.

Rosemary Sage Bread Recipe

Fill your home with the aroma of fragrant, homemade rosemary bread.

Customizable Cornbread Recipe

Our basic cornbread recipe can be embellished with a variety of sweet and savory mix-ins.

DIY Caramel Apple Bar

Bring the flavors of fall to your next gathering with a DIY caramel apple bar.

Light Pasta Recipes For Spring And Summer

Pasta isn’t just about hearty sauces and cozy nights in. Enjoy these fresh pasta recipes as the weather warms up.

Avocado Ice Cream: A Surprisingly Delicious Summer Treat

Celebrate summer with this avocado ice cream: a healthier alternative to a classic treat.